Freyssinet United States

Alkali-Silica Reaction in Concrete: Diagnosis

Alkali-Silica Reaction in Concrete: Causes, Signs and Management

Map cracking that spreads across a bridge deck, a pavement or a pier years after construction often points to alkali-silica reaction in concrete. In this reaction, the alkalis of the cement paste react with unstable silica in some aggregates and form a gel that swells with water and cracks the concrete from the inside.

The damage cannot be reversed, but an owner who confirms it early can still choose between drying, monitoring and strengthening. At Freyssinet USA, our repair projects on affected structures start by testing the cracked members to confirm it.

How Does a Condition Assessment Confirm Alkali-Silica Reaction in Concrete?

A concrete condition assessment confirms the reaction in 3 steps: a visual survey, crack mapping measurements and the laboratory examination of cores.

A concrete condition survey combines these steps with non-destructive and intrusive testing, because no surface sign alone proves the reaction.

Which Visible Signs Point to Alkali-Silica Reaction?

The visible signs of the reaction are 4 forms of cracking and movement that inspectors record on each member:

  • Map cracking: a random network of cracks, often wider at the center of a member and finer toward its edges, with a white or dark border along the crack.
  • Gel exudation and staining: a glassy or sticky deposit, or a dark damp staining, along the cracks where gel formation reaches the surface.
  • Pop-outs: small cone-shaped pieces lifted off the surface by a reacting particle just below it.
  • Closed joints and misalignment: joints squeezed shut, extruded joint sealant or members pushed out of line as the concrete expands.

The same signs can come from drying shrinkage, freeze-thaw damage or corrosion, so they only tell the inspector where to measure and where to core.

How Does the Cracking Index Measure Expansion in the Field?

The Cracking Index measures expansion in the field as the sum of the crack widths that cross reference lines drawn on the most cracked faces of a member.

Inspectors read each crack width along the lines using a crack comparator card or a magnifier, then divide the total by the line length to rate the extent of cracking on that face.

Each new reading is taken under similar weather, because temperature and moisture are factors that open and close the cracks.

Repeated over months or years, the readings show whether the expansion is still active or has slowed.

What Does Petrographic Examination of Concrete Cores Show?

Petrographic examination of concrete cores shows the gel, the reacted aggregate particles and the cracks that run from them into the cement paste.

Under a stereo microscope and a polarizing microscope, polished slabs and thin sections of the core show 3 findings that confirm the reaction:

  • Gel in voids and cracks: the presence of a glassy or white deposit lining the openings.
  • Reaction rims: dark rims around the siliceous particles that reacted.
  • Cracks from the particles: cracks that cross a particle, then branch into the paste.

The examination also identifies the rock types and minerals that reacted. Knowing the reactive rock type lets the owner check other members cast with the same stone.

Which Signatures Separate Alkali-Silica Reaction From Freeze-Thaw Damage?

Freeze-thaw damage scales the surface and opens microcracks parallel to it.

The cracks of the reaction start at reactive particles instead, run through the depth of the member and carry gel.

Signature Freeze-thaw damage Silica reaction
Crack pattern Fine cracks parallel to the surface, scaling of the top layer Map cracking that runs into the depth of the member
Origin of the cracks The cement paste, where water freezes in the pores Reactive particles in the stone
Deposits None specific Gel in cracks and voids, reaction rims
Location Exposed horizontal surfaces and edges Wherever moisture stays in the member

Both mechanisms need moisture, and they often act together on the same member. The core examination tells them apart, because the presence of gel points to the silica reaction as the cause of the deterioration.

What Causes Alkali-Silica Reaction in Concrete?

Alkali-silica reaction can only occur when 3 requirements are present together in the concrete: reactive silica in the aggregate, enough alkali in the pore solution and enough moisture.

An FHWA report on existing structures states that eliminating any one of these 3 conditions prevents the reaction, which is the basis of every prevention and management option for affected concrete.

Reactive Silica in the Aggregate

Reactive silica is the poorly crystalline or amorphous silica that some aggregates hold and that dissolves in a strongly alkaline pore solution.

Siliceous rocks such as chert, opal-bearing stone, volcanic glass or strained quartz carry this form of silica. Well-crystallized quartz, by contrast, stays stable in the same concrete.

The reactivity of a given quarry is a property of its minerals, which is why quarries are tested before their stone is used rather than judged by their rock name.

Alkali Hydroxides in the Pore Solution

The alkali hydroxides come from the sodium and potassium of the portland cement, which dissolve as the cement hydrates and raise the pH of the pore solution.

These hydroxide ions break the chemical bonds of the reactive silica at the surface of the particles.

A high alkali content in the cement and a high cement content in the mix both raise the alkali each cubic yard of concrete holds.

External alkalis: deicing salts on decks and pavements, or seawater on marine structures, add alkalis not present in the mix.

Internal Relative Humidity Above 80 Percent

Moisture keeps the chemical process going: the FHWA report on evaluating and treating structures damaged by the reaction cites an internal relative humidity of 80 percent as the target below which the expansion slows considerably.

Members with a constant moisture source show the worst damage. A deck under a leaking joint, a pier in a splash zone or a footing in wet soil keeps its humidity high, while a dry, sheltered element of the same concrete may barely crack.

Poor drainage and detailing that keep water on a surface decide, through the presence of moisture, where the expansion concentrates.

How Does Alkali-Silica Reaction Damage Concrete Structures?

Alkali-silica reaction weakens a concrete structure from the inside long before the surface shows it, most often in members exposed to moisture such as pavements, bridge decks, piers, abutments and dams.

How the Alkali-Silica Gel Swells and Cracks Concrete

The gel forms at the surface of the particles that react, absorbs water from the surrounding paste and swells.

The damage then builds in 3 stages, from the particle to the whole member:

  1. Growth: sodium, potassium and calcium from the pore solution feed its growth inside the particle and at its rim.
  2. Particle cracking: the swelling pressure cracks the particle first.
  3. Paste cracking: the resulting cracks extend into the cement paste and link up between particles.

This internal mechanism produces expansion of the whole member before any crack reaches the surface.

Stiffness Loss in Affected Members

The stiffness of affected concrete drops first: the reaction lowers the modulus of elasticity and the tensile strength more than the compressive strength.

A compressive test of cores alone underestimates the damage. Engineers add laboratory testing of stiffness or tensile strength, such as splitting tests or a stiffness damage test used on the cores, to rate the durability of the member.

Lower stiffness and tensile strength matter most where the member carries shear or relies on bond with its reinforcement, as in bridge caps, beams and slabs.

Secondary Damage Through the Cracks

The cracks of the reaction open a path for water and chlorides, which enables freeze-thaw damage and corrosion of the reinforcement.

Each of the 3 mechanisms then speeds up the other 2:

  • Corrosion: corroding bars crack the cover further.
  • Freeze-thaw: freezing water widens the existing cracks.
  • The reaction: the extra moisture that enters keeps it active.

That secondary deterioration, caused by water entering the cracks, is often what turns the first map cracking into a repair project years later.

How Are Aggregates Tested for Alkali-Silica Reactivity?

Specifiers test new aggregate sources for potential deleterious reactivity with a petrographic examination of the stone, then standardized expansion tests on mortar or concrete specimens.

Accelerated Mortar Bar Test

The accelerated mortar bar test gives a fast screening result: mortar bars made using the crushed aggregate soak in a hot sodium hydroxide solution, and their expansion is measured after a short storage period.

A low expansion clears the source for use.

A high expansion may not mean that field concrete will crack, because the test bath holds far more alkali, at a far higher temperature, than the pore solution of a real structure.

A quarry that fails this screening is then retested in concrete prisms before the project rejects its stone.

Concrete Prism Test

Compared with the mortar bar test, the concrete prism test is the reference test, because it uses real concrete with the aggregate at its normal grading.

The prisms are stored over water at high humidity and measured for many months.

The storage runs longer when a mixture with supplementary cementitious materials or lithium is evaluated.

An expansion below the specified limit marks a non-reactive aggregate or an effective mixture.

Tests of Mitigated Mixtures

When a reactive aggregate must be used, a mortar bar test of the planned blend of cement and fly ash, slag or silica fume checks whether the blend controls the expansion.

The miniature concrete prism test gives a concrete result much sooner than the full-size test. Its smaller prisms and crushed aggregate let a project test several cementitious combinations before the mix design is fixed.

How Is Alkali-Silica Reaction Prevented in New Concrete?

Prevention in new concrete removes the reactive silica or limits the alkali before the first pour.

How much prevention a mix needs depends on factors such as the potential reactivity of the aggregate, the exposure conditions of the element and its service life.

The specifier can then use 4 options to mitigate the risk, alone or combined:

  • Non-reactive aggregate: a source that passes the expansion tests takes the first requirement out of the mix.
  • Low-alkali cement: a cement with a low sodium and potassium content limits the alkali in the pore solution.
  • Supplementary cementitious materials: fly ash, slag or silica fume bind alkalis and lower the permeability of the paste.
  • Lithium admixtures: lithium nitrate added to the mix forms a gel that swells far less.

On a major bridge in a wet exposure, the mix often combines 2 or more of these options.

How Do Owners Manage Alkali-Silica Reaction Over a Structure’s Service Life?

An affected structure cannot be rid of the reaction, only slowed, so management aims at a longer service life rather than a cure of the chemical process.

The alkali and the reactive silica are already present, so only 2 remedies act on the reaction itself: drying the concrete and, in certain members, lithium treatment. The other measures treat its symptoms.

Moisture Control of Affected Members

Moisture control slows the reaction by cutting the presence of water until the concrete dries below the humidity it needs.

Drainage comes first: repaired deck joints, scuppers, flashing and slopes prevent water from reaching the member.

Breathable sealers such as silanes, or elastomeric coatings that let water vapor out, then keep rain and splash from wetting the concrete again.

Warning: a sealer that traps moisture inside does the opposite. Vapor permeability is the first property to check on any coating.

Lithium Treatment of Hardened Concrete

Lithium treatment may change gel formation in some hardened members, with lithium nitrate applied by topical spray, vacuum impregnation or electrochemical methods.

Penetration depth limits it: a topical treatment reaches only the outer layer of a thick member.

Vacuum and electrochemical methods drive the ions deeper, at a higher cost per member.

Its use suits thin elements such as decks and pavements better than massive piers.

Expansion Monitoring Over Time

Expansion monitoring repeats the crack mapping and adds measurements of length change across the member, under similar weather each time.

Inspectors read the distance between reference studs glued on a face, or use installed extensometers, at each visit. The trend shows whether the expansion continues, slows after the drainage work or calls for a repair or strengthening decision.

When Does Alkali-Silica Reaction Damage Call for Structural Strengthening?

Damage from the reaction calls for strengthening when expansion or cracking threatens the capacity of a member, for example when wide cracks open through a bridge cap or a pier.

Structural strengthening restores that capacity but leaves the chemical reaction active, so the member also gets moisture control.

Restraining Alkali-Silica Reaction Expansion With Post-Tensioning

Post-tensioning restrains the expansion in the direction of the applied stress, which limits the cracking that runs across it.

External tendons or bars stressed against the member suit bridge and highway elements and thin arch dams.

Large masses are a poor fit: the expansive process develops huge forces there, and the restraint needs periodic destressing.

Confining Alkali-Silica Reaction Expansion in Columns

In affected columns and piers, a fiber-reinforced polymer wrap or a reinforced concrete jacket confines the expansion from the outside.

Both options restore part of the strength and durability of the member, such as the axial capacity of a cracked pier column.

Wraps and jackets treat the symptoms of the expansion only, often temporarily. Inspectors check them for bulging or new cracking at each visit, as the reaction keeps going inside.

Partial Replacement of Damaged Concrete

Partial replacement removes the concrete that freeze-thaw damage or corrosion has added to the reaction, and rebuilds the section with the new repair materials used for the member.

On a pavement, this means patch or full-depth repairs at the joints. On a bridge member, it means a repair down to sound concrete around the bars.

Drainage and monitoring stay in place after the repair, since the reaction continues in the remaining concrete.

Assess and Repair Alkali-Silica Reaction Damage With Freyssinet USA

Confirming the reaction early lets an owner plan drying, monitoring or strengthening before the expansion costs a member its capacity.

At Freyssinet USA, we combine non-destructive and intrusive testing in our condition assessments to find the cause, extent and rate of the deterioration, and our crews then repair and strengthen bridges and other concrete structures across the US.

Request a condition assessment of your cracked structure.

Frequently Asked Questions About Alkali-Silica Reaction in Concrete

Is Alkali-Silica Reaction the Same as Alkali-Aggregate Reaction?

No: alkali-aggregate reaction is the family name for reactions between the alkalis of concrete and some aggregates, and alkali-silica reaction is its most common form. The other form, alkali-carbonate reaction, involves certain carbonate rocks instead of silica.

Why Is Alkali-Silica Reaction Called Concrete Cancer?

The nickname comes from damage that grows inside the concrete for years before it shows and that cannot be reversed once established. Engineers keep the name alkali-silica reaction, because it names a chemical cause that petrography and expansion tests can identify.

How Does Alkali-Carbonate Reaction Differ From Alkali-Silica Reaction?

Alkali-carbonate reaction involves certain dolomitic carbonate rocks instead of reactive silica, and it produces little or no gel. It is far less common, and the fly ash or slag that controls the silica reaction does not reliably control it, so the usual answer is to avoid the rock.

Is There Silica in Concrete?

Yes: sand and most coarse aggregates are largely silica, mostly as stable crystalline quartz. Only a small share of poorly crystalline forms in some sources reacts, which is why concretes with the same sand content can behave very differently.